Why Fixing Your Car Is Cheaper (and Smarter) Than Buying a New One

Oct 29, 2024

When your car starts showing signs of wear, the question often arises: should I repair it or just buy a new one? While the idea of a shiny new vehicle is enticing, a closer look at the associated costs shows that fixing your current car is often the more economical—and in many cases, preferable—choice. Here’s a deep dive into why sticking with your current ride makes financial sense and can offer you more freedom on the road.


1. The True Cost of Buying a New Car

When you purchase a new car, you’re not just paying for the car itself. There are additional costs and fees that can quickly add up, significantly raising the overall price. Let’s break down some of these often-overlooked expenses:

A. High Monthly Payments and Rising APR Rates

With rising interest rates, financing a new car has become considerably more expensive. Currently, APRs on new vehicles average around 6-7%, but some buyers are seeing rates closer to 10% or more depending on credit history and lender terms. Here’s what that looks like over time:

  • Monthly Payments: A typical new car loan now averages around $700 per month. Over a five-year loan term, that comes out to $42,000—just in loan payments.
  • Interest Paid: If you’re financing a $35,000 car at 7% APR over five years, you’re looking at nearly $6,500 in interest alone, which increases your actual cost to over $41,500.
  • Depreciation: Cars lose value fast—around 20% in the first year. A $35,000 car will be worth about $28,000 after just 12 months.

B. Higher Insurance Premiums

Newer cars typically come with higher insurance premiums. Insurance companies calculate premiums based on a car’s replacement cost, safety features, and repair expenses, which are often higher for new models.

  • Comprehensive and Collision: Newer cars often require comprehensive and collision coverage, which can add hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars annually to your policy.
  • Increased Deductibles: Higher coverage often means higher deductibles, increasing the out-of-pocket costs if you ever need to make a claim.
  • Premium Increases Over Time: Many people don’t realize that premiums often increase year over year, even if you maintain a clean driving record, due to the car’s higher value.

C. Hidden Dealer Fees and Registration Costs

Purchasing a new car often includes a host of additional fees:

  • Dealer Fees: Documentation fees, dealer prep fees, and destination charges can add $500 to $1,500 to your total cost.
  • Sales Tax: The average sales tax on a new car adds another 5-10% to the price, depending on your location.
  • Registration Costs: Some states charge higher registration fees for new vehicles, which means you could end up paying hundreds more in the first year alone.

2. The Cost Benefits of Fixing Your Current Car

In comparison, repairing your existing car is much less costly. Here are some key advantages:

A. Lower Overall Repair Costs

While repairs can be expensive, they pale in comparison to the total cost of purchasing a new vehicle:

  • Average Repair Costs: A new transmission may run $3,000 to $5,000, and major engine repairs can cost up to $6,000, but these are often one-time expenses.
  • Regular Maintenance: Routine maintenance like oil changes, brake repairs, and tire replacements cost far less annually than new car payments.
  • Cost of Parts: Older cars are often cheaper to repair because parts are more readily available and labor is less complex compared to newer, high-tech models.

B. Avoiding Depreciation

When you keep your current car, you avoid the rapid depreciation that comes with buying new. For example:

  • Value Retention: With an older car, depreciation slows, allowing you to get more value out of every repair. Each dollar spent prolongs its life without reducing the value as drastically.
  • Higher Trade-in Value: When it’s finally time to upgrade, well-maintained cars tend to fetch better prices on the resale market.
  • Why fixing your car is cheaper You are already getting the car at its lowest value!

3. New Car Technology: Not Always a Plus

Newer cars come equipped with an array of high-tech features, some of which are less desirable, especially for drivers who prefer a more straightforward driving experience.

A. Tracking and Privacy Concerns

Many modern cars are now fitted with GPS tracking, driving habit monitoring, and even cameras. While marketed as safety features, they can compromise privacy:

  • GPS and Data Collection: Some manufacturers track driver locations and habits, and some may share that data with third parties. This can be unsettling for those who value privacy.
  • Subscription Features: Automakers increasingly add subscription-based services for features that used to come standard. For instance, heated seats, navigation, and remote start may require monthly fees.
  • Software and Security Risks: The more software in a vehicle, the higher the risk of bugs, hacking, or other vulnerabilities, which can lead to costly repairs or even unsafe conditions.
  • Why fixing your car is cheaper Older cars do not have bloated, paid subscriptions

B. Complexity and Repair Costs

New cars are more technologically complex, which means they often cost more to repair and maintain due to:

  • Proprietary Systems: Modern cars often include manufacturer-specific software and systems, requiring specialized knowledge and equipment to repair, which drives up labor costs.
  • Reliability: High-tech components can fail more frequently and tend to be more expensive to replace than the simpler systems in older models.

4. Long-Term Ownership: The Smart Financial Choice

Fixing you car is cheaper: Here’s why:

  • Lower Monthly Costs: Instead of budgeting $700+ for a car payment, you can invest a fraction of that amount each month into maintenance and repairs, keeping your car in good shape.
  • Financial Freedom: Without the burden of a new car payment, insurance premium hikes, and costly maintenance, you’ll have more room in your budget for other expenses or savings.
  • Predictability: An older, well-maintained car has predictable expenses. You know its quirks, which repairs might come next, and exactly how it drives, which is a level of reliability many drivers value.

Conclusion: Why Stick with Your Current Car?

With the high cost of purchasing, insuring, and maintaining a new car, the financial advantage of keeping your current vehicle becomes clear. Add in the hidden fees, potential loss of privacy from tracking features, and expensive repair costs for new models, and it’s easy to see why maintaining an older car makes more sense. By investing in repairs and routine maintenance, you’ll save thousands and enjoy the freedom that comes with driving a vehicle that’s truly yours—without all the financial baggage of a new car.

Shop

Car Gurus

Why fixing your car is cheaper

Skip to content